This is usual Qadyani Argument that we believe in same Qur’an and we donot believe in Any other Quran as some of the Mullahs Point towards them . Quranic Verses are also Clear that “to believe in came upon you(prophet Mohammad pbuh) and that came before him “. While taking a big U turn Qadyanis /Ahmadis again come with claim that exactly they believe in same Quran as Muslims Do…. But What About tazkirah , that is collection of “WAHI AND ROYA AND KASHF ” I.e revelations came upon Mira Qadyani .What About Writings of Mirza Qadyani ? what about verses of Quran that Mirza Qadyani claimed to came upon himself.
Mirza Qadyani says in Tazkirah page 548 (Urdu version ) says ” QURAN ARE WORDS OF MY MOUTH “, while Kalimatal Fasl Mirza basher M.A says ” We say where is Quran ? If Quran was their then there was no Need to come of any one .The problem is Quran has been lifted from the World.That’s why there was a need that Mohammad Should come in metaphoric sense in world and Quran should be descend upon him.
He further says “With the coming of Promised Messiah one difference (in the meaning of Kalima) has occurred and that is that before the advent of Promised Messiah, in the meaning of ‘Mohammad ur Rasoolullah’ only prophets of bygone days were included, but with the advent of Promised Messiah, one more prophet has been added to the meaning of Mohammad ur Rasoolullah … thus to enter in Islam it is still the same Kalima, the only difference is that the advent of Promised Messiah has added one more prophet to its meaning…we don’t need a new Kalima, because Promised Messiah is nothing separate from Holy Prophet, as he says: ‘saara wujoodi wujoodahoo (my person became his person)’ and ‘he who differentiates between me and Mustafa has not seen me and not recognised me’ … thus Promised Messiah is Mohammad Rasoolullah himself who has come again in this world to spread Islam, therefore we do not need any new Kalima. Yes if someone else had come then we may have required it — thus think all of you.”
(Kalimatal Fasl p.158 by Mirza Bashir Ahmad)
Related posts /research .
